When most homesteaders consider getting poultry for any goal, the very first birds that spring to thoughts are chickens, naturally. And that’s with good cause! Chickens are low-cost, extremely productive, typically simple to look after, and a cinch to maintain even in case you have a small yard.
However geese are additionally fairly fashionable, traditionally and at present, and they’re actually gaining steam by way of reputation currently. They’ll, in any case, provide you an identical issues that your chickens do within the type of meat and eggs.
Because of this, some individuals assume they’re broadly interchangeable relating to care and conserving, however there are main variations that it is advisable to learn about earlier than you carry dwelling a flock.
I’ll be evaluating each facet that these two species share on this article so you can also make a well-informed choice.
| Chickens | Geese | |
| Dimension | Typically smaller, 5.25-6 lbs on common | Typically bigger, 6.25-8 lbs on common |
| House Necessities | 8-10 sq ft run, 4 sq ft coop per chicken | 10-15 sq ft run, 5-6 sq ft home per chicken |
| Shelter | Elevated coop, roosting bars, nesting bins | Floor-level, no roosts, open shelter |
| Water Necessities | Ingesting water solely | Ingesting, consuming, cleansing, swimming |
| Dietary Necessities | Omnivores, decrease protein and niacin wants | Omnivores, increased protein and niacin wants |
| Cleanliness | Messy | Extraordinarily messy, particularly with water |
| Local weather Tolerance | Good chilly tolerance, higher warmth tolerance | Wonderful chilly tolerance, much less warmth tolerant |
| Vulnerability to Predation | Extra weak general, higher probabilities of escape | Much less weak typically if on water, simpler prey on land |
| Noise Issue | Noisy throughout day, quiet at night time | Quieter general, however energetic at night time |
| Friendliness | Will be pleasant, some breeds standoffish | Typically friendlier, extra prone to bond with people |
| Egg Variations | Smaller, 2 oz, oval form | Bigger, 3 oz, extra elongated |
| Egg Output | Many breeds lay 300+ eggs/yr | Typically fewer, some breeds match chickens |
| Lifespan | As much as 6 to 10 years on common | 8 to12 years on common |
Dimension
On common, chickens are smaller than geese and weigh much less, often between 5 1/4 and 6 lb on common. Your common home duck, in distinction, often weighs between 6 1/4 and eight lb.
However, there are exceptions on each ends of the spectrum for each breeds. Bantams may weigh solely a pound or somewhat extra, whereas tiny geese just like the diminutive and noisy Name breed may weigh not more than a few kilos.
Giant breed chickens just like the Jersey Big or Malay can simply clear 10 lb, whereas large geese like German Pekins or Muscovies will weigh about the identical and even heavier.
House Necessities
As a rule of thumb, all the time plan on geese needing extra room than chickens inside their shelter, within the run, and in your property when allowed to free-range.
As a common guideline, your common hen will want round 8 to 10 sq. ft of house within the run, per grownup chicken, and 4 sq. ft of coop house.
Geese want considerably extra space of their coop, wherever from 10 to fifteen sq. ft per grownup chicken in a run, and 5 – 6 sq. ft per grownup of their home (the frequent time period for a duck shelter).
And as all the time, extra is healthier for stopping stress, decreasing cleansing necessities, and enhancing general well-being. For each species, bigger people or breeds will want much more room, whereas you will get by with much less room for smaller breeds.
Shelter
The primary main distinction we encounter when evaluating the 2 poultry birds is their shelter necessities.
Chickens typically want a barely elevated shelter that has elevated roosting bars for sleeping on the within. That’s as a result of chickens instinctively search out increased floor after they go to mattress at sunset.
Chickens, given some other selection, aren’t energetic at night time. A great hen coop can even characteristic nesting bins in order that hens can have a secure and constant place to put their eggs.
Geese, alternatively, are completely happy to sleep at floor stage and may make do with a easy construction that doesn’t want roost bars and often gained’t want nesting bins both.
Home geese have a tendency to put eggs in out-of-the-way locations or wherever else that will get the hen’s consideration.
Nonetheless, geese are usually energetic at night time as a result of they take periodic naps all through the day. You shouldn’t shut geese up inside a shelter at dusk if you happen to can keep away from it as a result of this could make them anxious and antsy.
An open three-sided shelter with overhead safety or a four-sided shelter with an simply accessible duck door is ideal for them, however this has different penalties we’ll must cope with later.
Water Wants
Chickens and geese each want water to stay, in fact. Each species should have entry to an infinite provide of consuming water with a purpose to keep hydrated.
However as anticipated, geese have even better water necessities than chickens do as a result of they want water with a purpose to eat correctly, clear themselves, and swim.
This doesn’t imply you want a lake or perhaps a pond in your property, although the latter is nice to have. You’ll want a small water characteristic or pool, or on the very least an in-ground water trough, that your geese have limitless entry to.
You’ll discover geese taking and dipping their meals within the water to assist them swallow it and routinely dunking their heads and our bodies to assist them keep clear and deal with their feathers.
Chickens don’t take standard baths however as an alternative take mud baths. They significantly desire to keep away from being immersed in water if they will keep away from it.
Dietary Necessities
Each species are omnivores and eat an analogous weight loss program that consists of bugs, grains, seeds, and plant matter. Geese can even eat all kinds of aquatic organisms, snails, slugs, and so forth.
Nutritionally optimized feed is, as all the time, an incredible selection for each birds. Chickens can eat duck feed, and geese can eat hen feed with no in poor health results so long as it’s not medicated, however neither is right for the opposite.
Particularly, geese want extra protein and much more niacin, or vitamin B3, in comparison with chickens.
It’s potential for geese to subsist on non-medicated hen feed so long as you give them supplemental protein and niacin to assist make up the distinction, although this apply is mostly discouraged by seasoned duck keepers.
Cleanliness
I’ve received unhealthy information for you right here: each species are fairly messy as they poop usually left and proper. Left to their very own gadgets with out your intervention, each will flip their shelter and their run, and some other locations they frequent, right into a stinking, mucky mess.
However if you happen to thought chickens have been unhealthy, you haven’t seen something but: geese are extremely messy. They splash water all over the place when they’re consuming and grooming, and after they take a dip within the pond or pool and get out, they are going to monitor water all over the place.
Mud and mould are two fixed issues you’ll have to remain on high of if you happen to’ve received geese.
Local weather Tolerance
Each of those birds are famously tolerant of chilly climate, however geese have the sting. They’ve a thicker layer of fats for insulation, typically, and their feathers are supremely waterproof.
Which means most geese are greater than comfy effectively under freezing, and so long as they’ve a dry shelter to retreat to, you gained’t have a lot to fret about…
You’ll have to pay extra consideration to chickens when the temperature dips in the direction of freezing, however they’re extra tolerant of excessive temperatures in comparison with geese.
Most chickens do okay at 80°F / 26°C or somewhat hotter, however regulate geese which are exterior within the solar on the similar temperature and guarantee they’ve entry to water for swimming to allow them to quiet down.
Offering shade is a should for each species.
Vulnerability to Predation
Extra unhealthy information: each chickens and geese are extremely weak to ground-bound and flying predators, however chickens have a tendency to remain on the menu extra usually.
All kinds of critters like foxes, coyotes, raccoons, possums, home canine, snakes, birds of prey, mountain lions, bears, and extra will love nothing greater than to make a meal of both chicken, although smaller predators like raccoons and snakes usually prey on chicks, ducklings, and eggs.
The bigger dimension of geese might show a deterrent to among the smaller birds of prey, and if they’ve entry to a considerable water characteristic, they are going to readily take to the water to flee terrestrial predators.
Nonetheless, they’re clumsier and slower on land in comparison with chickens, and so are a neater goal in the event that they aren’t on the water.
Noise Issue
Each of those birds are noisy, although you’ll have to choose your poison relying in your preferences.
Chickens, significantly roosters, are usually very chatty in the course of the day, although this varies from breed to breed and flock to flock. Geese are usually quieter general, however as a result of they’re energetic at night time, you’ll must take heed to them quack and hiss even throughout nighttimes.
Considerably surprisingly, it’s feminine geese that are usually loads noisier than males. It is because females are extra social and spend extra time speaking with their flockmates and in addition with their people.
Friendliness
Chickens and geese may be fairly pleasant with individuals, given correct upbringing and interplay.
As soon as once more, breed variations play a giant half right here: some hen breeds are well-known for friendliness, just like the Buff Orpington and Faverolles. Geese, although, are usually friendlier and nearer with their individuals than chickens are, all issues being equal.
For those who spend quite a lot of time with and child your geese, don’t be stunned after they comply with you round at any time when they will see you. In distinction, chickens usually tend to be standoffish or maintain to themselves even when they do such as you.
That is only a tough guideline, although, and also you’ll discover that particular person birds and flocks have their very own personalities and preferences on this regard.
Egg Variations
For thus many keepers of geese or chickens, eggs are the primary cause why they received into poultry within the first place.
Each may be nice selections if you would like a gentle provide of the freshest and best-tasting eggs you’ve ever tried, however there are nonetheless appreciable variations you’ll have to learn about.
Egg Traits, Form, and Dimension
Hen eggs, as a rule, are smaller than duck eggs and are often somewhat lighter, averaging round 2 oz. They’ve a tapering, oval form with gently domed ends.
Duck eggs are larger, although, they weigh round 3 ozor somewhat extra, and are noticeably extra elongated with a prominently rounded slender finish. Duck eggs are additionally extra generally colourful or speckled in comparison with hen eggs.
Duck eggs have a markedly richer style in comparison with these from their hen cousins, and this is because of increased quantities of fats and protein.
Output
Chickens and geese differ somewhat bit relating to output, and most hen breeds are extra prolific layers than your common duck.
Leghorns, Australorps, and Orpingtons can lay upwards of 300 eggs yearly for the primary few years of their life so long as they’re in good well being. Nonetheless, some birds may cease laying within the wintertime when days get shorter.
Most duck breeds aren’t that prolific, although some, just like the Khaki Campbell, can clear 300 eggs a yr. Most geese are additionally extra prone to lay eggs year-round; one thing to contemplate if you happen to’re fearful a few winter stoppage.
Lifespan
The lifespan of those two chicken species is analogous, on common, however geese are inclined to stay somewhat longer. Most chickens will high out at round 10 years outdated, although these residing older than that and in comparatively good well being are hardly unusual.
Your common home duck breed will stay between 8 and 12 years, and even older, in perfect situations. Nonetheless, some duck breeds, just like the American Pekin, are recognized for a comparatively brief lifespan, round 6 years on common.
Elevating Chickens and Geese Collectively
All in all, it is potential to boost grownup geese and chickens collectively so long as you deal with the shelter and house necessities for every.
Attempting to maintain them in the identical shelter, until it’s an outsized coop or a small barn, might be not price it contemplating how messy geese are. They’ll make the bedding inside moist, and that may trigger issues in your chickens, and quick.
One thing else to fret about are pecking order points between the 2 breeds, particularly in case your chickens have a number of roosters within the flock.
By no means do you have to enable hens from both species to boost younger in a combined flock; geese are prone to trample chicks as a consequence of their better dimension, and aggression between protecting mother and father is frequent.
Like what you learn?
Then you definitely’re gonna love my free PDF, 20 frequent survival objects, 20 unusual survival makes use of for every. That is 400 whole makes use of for these dirt-cheap little objects!
We is not going to spam you.
